FREE SHIPPING EVERY DAY Order within 46 hours and 43 minutes to ship Monday

Sign In to Earn Rewards

SIGN IN For Best Experience

Earn 3% in Rewards Credit for every dollar you spend.
Convenient Tracking
Speedier Checkout

Sign In Create Account

Sort

FILTERS (5) 56 FOUND Reset Done

- Right 56 matching results
- Left 39 matching results
- 9"
- 9.50"
- 10"
- 10.50"
- 10.75"
- 11"
- 11.25"
- 11.33"
- 11.50"
- 11.75"
- 12"
- 12.25"
- 12.50"
- 12.75"
- 13"
- 13.50"
- 14"
- 15"
- 27.50"
- 7"
- 8"
- 9.75"

Coming Soon

Right 12.50" First Base Second Base Third Base

56 FOUND

Right 12.50" First Base Second Base Third Base CLEAR ALL

Popular Latest Avg. Rating Savings $: Low to High $: High to Low

Marucci Acadia 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: MFG3AC37S1 ^$119^.95

Rawlings Heart of the Hide 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: PRORFM18-17BCS ^$309^.95 - ^$319^.95 $329.99

Wilson A2000 AC4 Amanda Chidester 12.5" Fastpitch First Base Mitt: WBW101017125 ^$139^.95 - ^$169^.95 $329.95 Used from $154.95 5

Angled front view of a gray fastpitch mitt with A2000 and Wilson logos, featuring a red W on the white palm.

Wilson A2000 SuperSkin FP1B 12.50" Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: WBW100219125 ^$239^.95 $329.95 2

Wilson A2000 Autism Speaks SuperSkin V125 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: WBW102109125 ^$179^.95 - ^$219^.95 $349.95

Wilson A2000 1677 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW103459125 ^$279^.95 $329.95 Used from $249.95

Angled view of a white leather softball glove with gray lacing, a basket web, and gold Mizuno logos.

Mizuno MVP Prime 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: GMVP1250PF4W ^$119^.95 1

Front view of a gray baseball mitt with black lacing, red stitching, and A1000 and Wilson logos on palm.

Wilson A1000 1620 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW101452125 ^$139^.95 $199.95 2

Marucci Caddo 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: MFGCDFP125 ^$89^.95

Rawlings Renegade 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: RFBMB ^$79^.95 13

Angled front view of a gray and teal fastpitch softball glove with a woven back and PROFESSIONAL on the palm.

Easton Professional Collection ColorSplash 2.0 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: PCFP125-3GM ^$139^.95 $249.99

Wilson A1000 1620 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW102587125 ^$119^.95 - ^$129^.95 $199.95 1

Rawlings Sandlot 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: SFM18S ^$99^.95 6

Angled view of two white fastpitch softball gloves, one showing a palm with pink PROFESSIONAL branding, the other a woven back.

Easton Professional Collection ColorSplash 2.0 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: PCFP125-3WCBP ^$219^.95 $249.99

Mizuno MVP Prime 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: GXF50PB4 ^$129^.95 3

Wilson A2000 Classic 1679 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW102097125 ^$329^.95

Front view of a pink fastpitch softball mitt with teal lacing, A2000 and Wilson logos, and a teal web.

Wilson A2000 FP1B 12.5" Fastpitch Softball First Base Mitt: WBW103949125 ^$269^.95 $329.95 Used from $189.95

Mizuno Prospect 12.5" Youth Baseball First Base Mitt: GXF102-BLK ^$79^.95 $89.95 30

Mizuno Prime Elite 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: GPE1250F2 ^$189^.95

Front view of a gray and blue softball glove with gold trim and Liberty Advanced and Rawlings branding.

Rawlings Liberty Advanced Color Series 4.0 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: RLA125-18GCB ^$189^.95 $199.99

Mizuno Prospect Select 12.5'' Fastpitch Softball Glove: GPSL1250F3 Black ^$69^.95

Front view of a teal, white, and purple fastpitch softball glove with tan lacing and A2000 and Wilson on the palm.

Wilson A2000 T125 12.5" Fastpitch Softball Glove: WBW103947125 ^$279^.95 $329.95 Used from $199.95

Front view of a gray Wilson A2000 baseball glove with tan lacing and white trim.

Wilson A2000 SuperSkin T125 12.5'' Fastpitch Softball Glove: WBG0701225 ^$329^.95

Front view of the tan leather palm and deep pocket of this first base mitt featuring thick black lacing and a black leather shell.

Mizuno Franchise 12.5" Baseball First Base Mitt: GXF90B5 ^$89^.95

Load More Products

Put Our Expertise to Work

We know gloves - and we’re here to help you find the perfect fit. Get the right one for your game with these resources:

Sizing Guide

Determine the right size glove for you or your player

Glove Coach

Get just-for-you glove recommendations

Resource Guide

Find helpful information written by our roster of Experts

support@justgloves.com

4.9 Star Rating, Google Customer Reviews